Value-based care pays for results across a population instead of, or on top of, payment for each service. For a practice manager, the practical question is not whether to "go value-based" but how much financial risk to take, through which contract, and whether the practice can see and act on its own patients' data well enough to succeed. Most practices will run fee-for-service and value-based arrangements side by side for years, so the goal is to build capabilities that pay off under both.
This primer explains the payment spectrum, the main Medicare vehicles as they stand for 2026, what changes in day-to-day operations, and a readiness checklist you can work through with your clinical and billing leads. Commercial and Medicare Advantage contracts vary widely, so use the Medicare programs here as a reference point and read your own contracts closely.
The spectrum from fee-for-service to capitation
Value-based arrangements sit on a range defined by how much of the cost and quality outcome the practice is accountable for.
- Fee-for-service: each visit, test, and procedure is paid separately. Volume drives revenue and there is no direct reward for keeping patients well.
- Fee-for-service with quality adjustments: claims are still paid per service, but a bonus or penalty is applied based on reported quality and cost. Medicare's Merit-based Incentive Payment System (MIPS) works this way.
- Shared savings, one-sided: the practice or its ACO keeps a share of savings if spending for its attributed patients comes in under a benchmark and quality standards are met, with no penalty if spending runs over.
- Shared savings and losses, two-sided: the same arrangement, but the organization repays part of the overspending. Upside sharing rates are usually higher in exchange.
- Capitation or global risk: the organization receives a set amount per patient, or is accountable for close to the full total cost of care, and manages care within it.
Moving along the spectrum raises both the potential reward and the need for reliable data, cash reserves, and care processes that reach patients between visits.
Medicare vehicles in 2026
Medicare Shared Savings Program (MSSP). The largest Medicare ACO program. CMS reports 511 ACOs participating in 2026, serving 12.6 million people with Traditional Medicare, according to its 2026 ACO participation highlights. ACOs choose between the BASIC track, which runs from one-sided Levels A and B to two-sided Levels C through E, and the ENHANCED track. Under the regulations, an ACO that meets the quality standard can share up to 40 percent of savings at Levels A and B and 50 percent at Level E of the BASIC track, and 75 percent in the ENHANCED track, subject to payment limits. CMS also reports that 82.8 percent of MSSP ACOs in 2026 are in Level E or ENHANCED, the levels that count as Advanced Alternative Payment Models.
The CY 2026 Physician Fee Schedule final rule changed the path for newer ACOs. For agreement periods beginning on or after January 1, 2027, one-sided participation is limited to an ACO's first agreement period on the BASIC track glide path, and ACOs inexperienced with performance-based risk must move more quickly to Level E or ENHANCED. The same rule requires ACOs entering a new agreement period to have at least 5,000 assigned beneficiaries in the third benchmark year, and caps savings and losses at a lower amount for ACOs below 5,000 in any benchmark year.
ACO REACH and its successor, LEAD. CMS reports 74 ACOs in the ACO REACH Model in 2026, caring for an estimated 1.7 million people. REACH concludes at the end of 2026. Its successor, the Long-term Enhanced ACO Design (LEAD) Model, is a voluntary 10-year model running from January 1, 2027 through December 31, 2036. It offers a Global Risk option, with up to 100 percent of savings and losses relative to the benchmark, and a Professional Risk option at up to 50 percent. CMS says LEAD is designed to include more small, rural, and independent practices and to focus on high-needs patients, including people dually eligible for Medicare and Medicaid. As of this writing, CMS lists the model as announced; check the LEAD page for participant selection and future application windows.
Other models. CMS also lists 23 ACOs in the ACO PC Flex Model in 2026, a primary care payment model that runs inside the Shared Savings Program. Specialists should note the Ambulatory Specialty Model finalized in the CY 2026 rule: a mandatory model that begins January 1, 2027, with five performance years ending December 31, 2031, focused on heart failure and low back pain.
The Quality Payment Program: MIPS and Advanced APMs
The Quality Payment Program has two paths for clinicians billing Medicare Part B. Under MIPS, the CY 2026 rule sets the 2026 performance period weights at 30 percent quality, 30 percent cost, 25 percent Promoting Interoperability, and 15 percent improvement activities. The performance threshold stays at 75 points for the 2026 through 2028 performance periods, and the maximum adjustment for the 2028 payment year is 9 percent in either direction, with scores at or below one-fourth of the threshold receiving the full negative adjustment. CMS has stated a goal of phasing out traditional MIPS in favor of MIPS Value Pathways (MVPs), which group measures by specialty or condition.
Clinicians who reach Qualifying APM Participant (QP) status through an Advanced APM are excluded from MIPS. Starting in 2026, Medicare uses two conversion factors: for CY 2026 the update for the qualifying APM conversion factor is 0.75 percent and for the nonqualifying conversion factor is 0.25 percent, as described in the same rule. QPs historically received a lump-sum APM incentive payment; under current law, QPs from the 2024 performance period onward receive the higher conversion factor update instead.
What changes operationally
The contract is the easy part. These are the four areas where practices feel the shift.
Attribution. Patients are assigned to an ACO or clinician based mostly on who provides their primary care services, and some patients can name their own primary clinician through voluntary alignment. MSSP ACOs choose prospective assignment or preliminary prospective assignment with retrospective reconciliation, which changes when you know your final list. Practices need a working roster, a way to spot attributed patients who have not been seen this year, and a habit of checking whether patients are getting most of their primary care elsewhere.
Quality measures. MSSP ACOs report the APM Performance Pathway (APP Plus) quality measure set, and the CY 2026 rule moves collection toward electronic clinical quality measures and Medicare CQMs. That means measures are pulled from structured data across the ACO's participants, so documentation habits matter: a blood pressure recorded in free text, or a screening documented only in a scanned letter, may not count.
Care gaps. Most quality measures come down to whether each eligible patient got a specific service in the period: a screening, a controlled reading, a follow-up after discharge. Gap closure is a weekly operational task with an owner, not a year-end report. Our guide to building a chronic care management program covers the staffing and workflow side of reaching patients between visits.
Data. You will be working from CMS claims data for your attributed patients, your own EHR, and often hospital admission and discharge notifications. Claims arrive with a lag, so the EHR and real-time event feeds drive day-to-day work while claims drive cost analysis. If the EHR and care management tools do not share one record, staff end up reconciling lists by hand; see our EHR integration guide.
How to assess readiness
Work through these questions with your practice leadership before signing a risk-bearing contract. A "no" is not disqualifying, but each one is a cost or a risk you should price in.
- Population: do you know how many Medicare and other value-based patients would likely be attributed to you, and is the panel large enough for results to reflect performance rather than chance?
- Baseline: do you know your current performance on the measures in the contract and your patients' utilization patterns, such as emergency visits and admissions?
- Data: can you produce a current list of attributed patients with open care gaps, by clinician, without manual spreadsheet work?
- Transitions: do you learn about admissions and discharges within a day or two, and is someone responsible for follow-up?
- Between-visit care: do you have staff and workflows for outreach to patients with chronic conditions, rising-risk patients, and those who have not been seen?
- Documentation: are measure-relevant data captured in structured fields that will flow to quality reporting?
- Finance: can the practice absorb a year in which shared savings are delayed or do not materialize, and for two-sided risk, repay losses?
- Governance: who reviews performance monthly and has authority to change workflows?
A common sequence is to strengthen MIPS performance and care management first, join a one-sided arrangement or an established ACO next, and take on two-sided risk once the data and processes have run for a full year.
Building capabilities that pay off under both models
Many of the capabilities that value-based contracts reward are also billable under fee-for-service today. Chronic care management, transitional care after discharge, and annual wellness visits all involve finding patients who need attention, reaching them between visits, and documenting the work in a structured way. Patients with both Medicare and Medicaid, a focus of LEAD, often need the most coordination; our piece on chronic disease management for dual-eligible patients covers what that looks like.
The aim is a single workflow in which the same outreach, follow-up, and documentation serve both the fee-for-service claim and the quality measure. Hoss Care's value-based care program support is built around that idea, with care gaps, follow-ups, and documentation in one place connected to the EHR. Whatever tools you use, start with the readiness questions above and with a clear read of the contracts you already hold.
Related articles
- PCM vs. CCM: Choosing the Right Care Management ProgramBest Practices · 5 min read
- CCM Software for MSOs: Keeping Care Consistent Across PracticesBest Practices · 4 min read
- Advanced primary care management (APCM): What the monthly service includesGetting Started · 4 min read
- Value-based careCare service
See it running in your practice
See how Hoss Care helps your team put these ideas to work, connected to the EHR you already run.